Brexitannia: The British Identity Crisis

By James Melville.

Brexit is a bit like someone sticking two fingers up at a window and then discovering it’s a mirror.

It is an enormous act of self harm based on an insecure delusion of what Britain was, what Britain is, and what Britain should be.

There is a long-held Little Englander optical delusion of Britain parading around like something out of the encore section of Last Night of the Proms. A place called Britain that should always rule the waves. This British identity framing is how the Britain’s Conductor-in-Chief, Boris Johnson, likes to orchestrate it.

This is delusional. Britain is now a battered ship Britannia sailing against the wind across stormy waters and travelling towards an iceberg, that because of a lack of planning and poor navigation, 52% of the crew somehow decided didn’t exist.

There was a time that Britain mattered internationally and was comfortable with its direction of travel. It is a country with an incredible history and many admirable values. The British ‘values’ of politeness, humour, endeavour, manners, creativity, multiculturalism, stoicism, civic pride, innovation, and community spirit were held in high esteem across the world. Sadly, these values appear to be getting drowned out by the sound of exceptionalism draped with the Little Englander flag of patriotism.

Britain is a place that gifted the world Shakespeare, Dickens, Keats, Brunel, Newton, Shackleton, Rowling, Attenborough, Burns, Hawking, Bowie, Lennon, McCartney and many many more. This brilliantly creative outward-looking confidence has now been replaced with the insular and insecure drumbeat of the Daily Mail, The Sun, Nigel Farage, Mark Francois, Katie Hopkins, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Boris Johnson and Tommy Robinson.

Genuinely awe-inspiring identity and pride has been replaced by an insecure and confused identity based on ethnic nationalism and England in particular, currently has an identity crisis.

This identity crisis seems to be embracing an introverted irrelevance that has been paradoxically embraced by an extroverted Prime Minister. Boris Johnson was pivotal to the victory of Brexit in the 2016 EU referendum. His appeal is based on two things. 1) Jingoistic faux-optimism 2) Deceitfulness, that rather regrettably, many people have fallen for. This great charlatan loves to sell a Brexitannia fantasy. A remnant of Britain’s persistent empire delusion and post-imperial confusion about its proper place in the world. Hanging on to non-essential expensive status symbols like a nuclear deterrent while its essential public services are underfunded and dismantled.

Britain, once renowned for its pragmatism, common sense and political stability has become the diametric opposite. It is now an island of wild and empty rhetoric, impulsive populism and political extremism combined with a dumbing down of political discourse. Political heavyweights have been replaced by shock-jock political lightweights. Common sense and decorum has left the island.

Over the past 3 years, British politics has failed to grasp the one thing that it really needed to grasp: what Brexit actually means. The reason nobody knows what Brexit means is because its roots stem from a 30 year psychodrama within the Tory party but without a strategic end game. Brexit is a way of deflecting from a multitude of problems facing our country – many of them caused by the Tory Party themselves.

Brexit has lurched from being a loose and vague idea based around the premise of sovereignty and freedom (while remaining in the single market), towards the grotesque possibility of crashing out of the EU without a deal – something what was never considered as a serious option back in the referendum of 2016. It’s now become the Brexit of choice for populist, demagogue empty vessels sailing in the far-right waters of British politics and the right-wing tabloids. It has happened because an inherent lack of understanding about Brexit and an existential confusion about the identity of Britain itself.

Britain is now showing disturbing symptoms of a full-blown identity crisis. A previously outward-looking and globalised country is now fractured by the backlash against the very model that made Britain strong.

The roots of this backlash stem from a gradual erosion of Britain’s industrial base, disenfranchised communities, economic decline and an increase in understandable resentment. But, this has been wilfully exploited by the readiness of the Tory Party in particular, to lie and peddle obvious untruths; to place party politics over and above the national interest and then to manipulate the narrative to create a perceived wisdom that somehow the problems within British society were the fault of foreign institutions or foreigners migrating to live and work in Britain. This con-trick has been going on for four decades.

Brexit is a huge step backwards for Britain. It is a step backwards for progressive internationalism and a step forward for regressive isolationism. British politics is now riddled with a deeply provincial and introverted mindset at a time when Britain should be at ease with playing a significant role towards outward-looking global expressionism.

Brexit has become an identity conflict in Britain. It is a binary choice, pitching those who see Britain as being a place of multicultural outward inclusivity against those who see Britain as a place of xenophobic inward parochialism. It is Danny Boyle’s London Olympics Opening Ceremony versus Last Night of the Proms. It is Remainers versus Brexiters. And when combining Brexit with Britain, it is unclear where Brexitannia is heading.



  1. This article outlines misguided #Remain thinking; the reality is that #Brexit enables #UK, in partnership with #Canada, #Australia & #NewZealand, to emerge with its democratic and moderating influence on #InternationalRelations. THIS is our global future, NOT the outdated thinking expressed in the article. #CDN #AUS #NZ #UK @CANZUKnews


  2. This article outlines misguided #Remain thinking, but reality is #Brexit enables #UK, in partnership with #Canada, #Australia & #NewZealand, to emerge as a new moderating influence in #InternationalRelations, distinct from the #EU. @CANZUK @CANZUKnews


  3. The truth is, that there comes a time when every ex-empire has to face the truth of its own smallness, in a national catharsis. With the Dutch, for example, it came both with the German occupation, and then with the loss of most of its navy off Java in February 1942, leading to the total wiping out of its empire. Yet after the war, the Netherlands became a founder member of the EU.

    For the UK, the year 2019, and the final decline and fall of the last of Europe’s ancien regimes, is just such a time. Yet I believe that the destruction of our illusions of faux imperial greatness could be the birth pangs of something better.


    1. A good observation Nigel..However there is one difference. With the decline of the British Empire, turning into the Commonwealth, many many of the empire then desired to come to UK, a small island. Then we had the EU with unlimited access together with anybody worldwide attracted by our politicians saying it is the best country accommodating all and sundry. When I was a youngster foreigners believed London was paved with gold.
      We have always had immigration but you can’t sink the ship.


    2. Great analysis and very true, people also forget that Churchill wanted to be part of the founding of European Common Market, and was stunned when France vetoed our entry, De Gaulle said that Britain would never be European and would be a constant source disunity, a trouble maker…. how right he has proven to be….

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Hello George. You are quite right regarding Churchill and DE Gaulle, who we sheltered during war. The only problem is that you have not gone far enough. The 7 well off and in the same mold countries have turned into 27, many poor, and now too big to control. The enlargement which Blair was involved in was at the behest of US to absorb newly independent buffer states near Russia Add to that free movement plus many from rest of the world and you are looking at social disaster. Trading is alright to worry about but we have not got enough housing etc at present so you are saying add to the problem. Likewise in freedom say we loose 10,000 engineers to Germany but receive 10,000 jobless from the rest of EU we balance the books but not skills base. However hotels would be happy.
        We must still be a thriving country hence all the illegal boat people who are risking their lives to come to UK, why?.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s